Natural Gas – Conversions, Vehicles and Technology

Into the Driver's Seat: States Take Action to Boost NGV Adoption

November 2012, Green Fleet Magazine - Feature

by Gregory Staple & Matthew Slavin

State governments are jumping into the driver’s seat when it comes to natural gas vehicles (NGVs). Led by Colorado Governor John Hickenlooper and Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin, 22 Democratic and Republican governors have created a multistate consortium to procure NGVs for their government fleets. The goal is to aggregate purchasing power and provide an economy-of-scale incentive for automakers to produce more NGVs at lower prices. But, the purchasing consortium belies a more important role that states have to play in accelerating the nation’s NGV market.

According to global energy consultancy IHS-CERA, several million NGVs could be on the nation’s roads in the future, up from 124,000 today. But, two key obstacles must first be overcome. First, the high incremental cost of purchasing vehicles fueled by natural gas — up to $85,000 for the heaviest duty combination truck-tractors — and, second, inadequate NGV fueling infrastructure.

New compressed natural gas (CNG) and liquefied natural gas (LNG) fueling stations may cost $1 million and $2 million or more respectively, 10 and 20 times the cost of a conventional gasoline station. In a survey by PLS Logistics, 23 percent of fleet executives pointed to high incremental vehicle costs as an impediment to adoption of NGVs. But, over twice as many — 53 percent — pointed to fueling access as the No. 1 barrier to adopting NGVs for their fleets.

States have a dramatic role to play in incentivizing private-sector investments in NGV fueling infrastructure, all the more so because the federal government is taking a back seat (e.g. congressional inaction on the Natural Gas Act of 2011).

The case for action is clear. A recent study by the American Clean Skies Foundation projected that $32 billion needs to be invested over the next decade to build a fueling network backbone, one that reaches a tipping point where natural gas is dispensed as a transportation fuel at 8,650 stations nationwide. The need to increase the number of public access CNG and LNG stations is particularly pronounced.

Deployment of this fueling network would drive a significant expansion in the number of fleet-operated NGVs, producing national benefits potentially valued in the hundreds of billions of dollars when measured in terms of reduced oil imports, lower pollution and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and reduced military spending. Building 8,650 new NGV fueling stations could help create 1.5 million new clean fuels technology jobs, significantly boosting the recovery of state economies.

The following examples highlight policies that states can embrace to incentivize private-sector investment in their NGV fueling networks.

Taking Advantage of Tax Credits
Clear evidence of the effectiveness of tax credits in incentivizing investment in fueling infrastructure can be seen in Oklahoma, where commercial entities are eligible for a state business income tax credit of up to 75 percent of fueling station development costs. There is no cap on the amount of credit that can be taken in any year, and credits can be carried forward for a five-year period. The tax credit has sparked development of more than 40 public-access CNG stations statewide; with a population of 3.8 million and 58 stations, Oklahoma is home to more public-access CNG stations per capita than any other state.

Oregon’s 35-percent Business Energy Tax Credit for alternative-fueled vehicles is unique in that it includes a “pass-through” provision — in addition to commercial entities, government and nonprofits can transfer the credit to another (commercial) entity with tax liability. In return, the transferring entity receives a lump sum payment. The pass-through formula proved highly effective in generating capital investment for wind energy projects, whereby such companies as Walmart served as pass-through partners, providing immediately available capital useful to developers in meeting significant up-front project costs.

A West Virginia business income tax credit that went into effect in 2011 might prove instrumental in sparking investment. A credit of 50 percent, up to a total of $250,000, is authorized for any individual entity. Particularly helpful: Public-access stations are eligible for a 25-percent bonus, raising the tax credit maximum to $325,000.

Grant Programs
The California Energy Commission (CEC) awards grants of up to $300,000 for CNG stations and $600,000 for LNG stations, providing the grants do not exceed 50 percent of station development costs. Notably, all recipients of CEC grants must agree to open their stations to public access. A sign of success: Since 2007, almost $13 million in grant awards have been made, leveraging investment in more than 30 new and upgraded CNG and LNG stations.

In 2011, Texas initiated an ambitious NGV infrastructure grant program as part of the plan to build the Clean Transportation Triangle linking Dallas, Houston, and San Antonio. Grants of $100,000 are available for stations that dispense CNG; $250,000 for LNG stations; and $400,000 for stations that dispense both CNG and LNG. All stations receiving grant funding must be public access. Grants totaling $3.15 million were announced in July that will leverage new investment in three LNG stations, 11 CNG stations, and one station dispensing both CNG and LNG.

Comment On This Story

Comment: (Maximum 10000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.



Fleet Management And Leasing

Jack Firriolo from Merchants will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Grants & Subsidies

Alternative Fueling Station Locator

Alternative Fueling Station Locator

Find your closest station or plan a route. Locate biodiesel, electric, ethanol, hydrogen, compressed natural gas (CNG), liquified natural gas (LNG), and propane across America.

Start Your Search