Making the Business Case for Alternative-Energy Vehicles

May 2012, Green Fleet Magazine - Feature


It is a vexing quandary for any fleet manager considering alternative-energy powered vehicles. How does one make a solid business case to support the higher acquisition cost of these advanced-technology vehicles, particularly with a fixed fleet capital budget?

Electric-powered vehicles can answer the long-term certainty of rising and continually volatile fuel prices as well as meet growing corporate sustainability concerns. Yet, today’s fleet manager must contend with the dilemma, “Does embracing these new technologies mean purchasing fewer replacement vehicles each cycle?”


The staff at Midland, Mich.-headquartered Dow Kokam have been working on resolving the conundrum. The company, which develop

s and manufactures technologically advanced battery solutions to power the next generation of plug-in hybrid (PHEVs) and battery-electric vehicles (BEVs), has created a flexible, easy-to-use tool to help calculate total cost of ownership (TCO) for these vehicles, according to Mira Inbar, senior marketing manager for commercial business.

Established in 2009, Dow Kokam is owned by the Dow Chemical Company, TK Advanced Battery LLC, and the French firm Groupe Industriel Marcel Dassault. Dow Kokam partners with OEMs to integrate its lightweight lithium-ion battery systems into light-, medium-, and heavy-duty vehicles and trucks, and also works with commercial, municipal, and utility fleets to determine the economic feasibility of operating the alt-powered vehicles.

Considering Hard & Soft Costs
An accurate TCO calculation accounts for a fleet vehicle’s hard and soft costs, as well as the specific details of its work cycle, according to Inbar. Hard costs include acquisition price, replacement value, fuel, depreciation, and maintenance. Soft costs cover factors more difficult to quantify, such as productivity, down time, safety, and efficiency.

“There is no one-size-fits-all technology for every fleet that offers payback,” Inbar said. “The technology must fit the vehicle’s work cycle, and the most effective TCO model accommodates all work cycle details.” These details include such factors as:
● Vehicle function.
● Hours of operation.
● Route terrain and environment.
● Cargo load.
● Type of route: how often the vehicle
 stops and starts.
● Idling time.
● Number of daily returns to the
warehouse, service center, depot, etc.

Identifying Payback Point
A “robust, adaptable-ready” tool that calculates lifecycle costs upfront and across vehicle types and functions, the Dow Kokam TCO model identifies the break-even point between conventional and advanced vehicle-power technologies, according to Inbar.

“All fleets want to manage their costs effectively. They want to be able to define the vehicle payback on lifecycle costs,” she added. The lack of accurate data on advanced-power technologies has hampered good business decision making regarding their implementation in fleets.

Working with an outside benchmarking data company, Dow Kokam developed its TCO model over six months, collecting and analyzing data across 18 vehicle types in all fuel-power categories — gasoline, diesel, PHEVs, and BEVs.

In addition, input from 10 of the top U.S. fleets was sought to ensure the TCO model covered all industry and utilization perspectives. Finally, Dow Kokam also established a Fleet Advisory Council to “weigh in on the model development,” Inbar said.

She also noted that the model is continually refined as more data becomes available from increased numbers of electric-powered vehicles on the road.

The Dow Kokam TCO model categorizes 10 fleet types (including commercial, delivery, beverage, and refuse) and lists 18 vehicle types, from four-door sedans and light-duty vehicles to medium-duty delivery vans and refuse trucks.

“We work with individual fleets to go through their particular vehicle composition. Using our model for every type of fleet vehicle and work cycle, we find the TCO to answer the question, ‘At what point do the operating cost and the acquisition cost break even? ’ ” Inbar explained.

Again, she emphasized, no technology will provide payback unless it matches the duty cycle as closely as possible.

Comment On This Story

Comment: (Maximum 10000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.



Fleet Management And Leasing

Merchants Experts will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Grants & Subsidies

Alternative Fueling Station Locator

Alternative Fueling Station Locator

Find your closest station or plan a route. Locate biodiesel, electric, ethanol, hydrogen, compressed natural gas (CNG), liquified natural gas (LNG), and propane across America.

Start Your Search


Market Trends

Mike Antich
Avoid Repeating Past Inefficiencies: Build the Truck to Match Today’s Application

By Mike Antich
I asked one fleet manager how he spec’ed replacement trucks for his fleet application. He related that many years earlier an OEM rep spec’ed out his trucks and he has been using the same formula ever since. While this may work in some cases, specifications should be defined by today’s fleet application to ensure the replacement truck is designed to accommodate current operational requirements rather than trying to make your operation conform to trucks spec’ed for yesteryear’s requirements.

Conduct an Efficiency Audit to Eliminate Waste in Your Fleet Budget

By Mike Antich

Driving Notes

Amy Winter-Hercher
2017 Subaru Impreza

By Amy Winter-Hercher
The redesigned 2017 Impreza has been built on Subaru’s new platform that improves stability and reduces road noise and vibration. The fuel-efficient, all-wheel-drive Impreza makes for a good commuter vehicle — available in either a sedan or hatchback.

2017 Mazda CX-5

By Eric Gandarilla

Nobody Asked Me, But...

Sherb Brown
Yes Virginia, There is Depreciation

By Sherb Brown
Depreciation is a necessary evil in our industry. Knowing your risks and knowing your OEM partners won’t make depreciation go away but it can make it more manageable.

Are You a Fleet Manager or Are You Just Managing a Fleet

By Sherb Brown

Fuel for Thought

Joe Thompson
Target Your Team by Pointing Toward Goals

By Joe Thompson
Without day-to-day goals that feed into the larger goals of the company, chances are that your team is just kicking assignments around.

Setting Your Standard for Customer Service

By Joe Thompson